Crossover Athletes Breaking into Rugby Often Struggle to Succeed
Crossover athletes—individuals who transition from one sport to another—have long been a subject of intrigue in the sporting world. The idea that a top-tier athlete from one discipline can seamlessly switch to another and excel is appealing, but in practice, the success rate is often lower than expected. This is particularly true when athletes attempt to transition into rugby, a sport that demands a unique combination of skills, physicality, and strategic understanding. The reasons why crossover athletes into rugby often struggle can be attributed to the sport’s unique demands, the steep learning curve, and the culture of rugby itself.
The Unique Physical Demands of Rugby
Rugby is a sport that requires an unusual blend of speed, strength, endurance, and toughness. While other sports may emphasize one or two of these attributes, rugby demands them all simultaneously. In contrast, sports like American football or basketball, which are popular sources of crossover athletes, tend to specialize athletes in specific roles, emphasizing either speed, agility, or strength. A football linebacker, for example, might be well-suited to the physical confrontations in rugby but may lack the endurance or spatial awareness needed for continuous play.
Rugby players must be versatile, handling the ball, tackling, and running at high intensity for 80 minutes with few breaks. This endurance component is particularly challenging for crossover athletes from sports like football, where play is more stop-start and athletes have time to recover between bursts of activity. Even athletes coming from sports with continuous play, such as soccer, may find rugby’s physicality and need for both defensive and offensive contributions overwhelming.
The Technical Skill Set
Rugby is a complex sport that demands a wide range of technical skills. Tackling, scrummaging, line-outs, rucking, and mauling are all fundamental aspects of the game that are foreign to athletes from most other sports. Even handling the ball in rugby is distinct—rugby passes are almost exclusively backward, which is counterintuitive for athletes accustomed to passing forward as in football or basketball.
Learning these skills requires not only time but also an understanding of the game’s intricate rules and strategies. Many crossover athletes struggle with this learning curve. While they may excel in one aspect of the game, such as tackling, their overall effectiveness is diminished by gaps in their skill set. Moreover, these skills must be executed under the pressure of high-speed play and physical confrontation, which adds another layer of difficulty.
Tactical Awareness and Game IQ
One of the most significant challenges for crossover athletes is developing the tactical awareness and “game IQ” that rugby demands. Unlike many other sports where plays are scripted and roles are narrowly defined, rugby requires players to make decisions on the fly based on the constantly shifting dynamics of the game. This requires a deep understanding of both team strategy and individual roles within that strategy.
Crossover athletes often struggle with this aspect of the game because it requires not just learning the rules but also understanding the nuances of rugby’s strategic elements. For example, understanding when to kick, when to run, and when to pass requires not just physical skill but also an intuitive sense of the game that comes from years of experience. This level of tactical awareness is difficult to acquire quickly, making it challenging for crossover athletes to adapt and excel in rugby.
The Culture and Mentality of Rugby
Rugby culture is another factor that can be a barrier for crossover athletes. Rugby has a distinct ethos that emphasizes teamwork, humility, and respect—both for teammates and opponents. The sport is known for its camaraderie, where off-field relationships and team cohesion are as important as on-field performance. This can be a stark contrast for athletes coming from more individualistic sports or those where star players are often put on a pedestal.
Moreover, the mentality required in rugby is one of resilience and adaptability. Rugby is a sport where players are expected to play through pain, make sacrifices for the team, and stay mentally focused for long periods. Crossover athletes may find the physicality of the sport mentally taxing, especially if they come from sports with less physical confrontation or different expectations around injury and recovery.
Case Studies: Successes and Failures
While there have been notable exceptions, such as Sonny Bill Williams, who transitioned successfully from rugby league to rugby union, the list of successful crossover athletes into rugby is relatively short. More often than not, the transition is fraught with difficulties, and many athletes either return to their original sport or fail to reach the same heights in rugby.
For example, former NFL player Jarryd Hayne, who attempted to transition into rugby with the Fiji Sevens team, found the going tough. Despite his undeniable athleticism, he struggled with the nuances of the game and the demands of the rugby sevens format. His experience highlights how difficult it can be to make such a transition, even for an elite athlete.
We have seen this experiment fail with the non-MLR iteration of the American Raptors. I do not question the fact that they are trying to do their best in growing the international game of rugby in the US by having more playing time to US born players, but I feel the crossover experiment fell off dramatically. Lots of the players the Raptors recruited had rugby experience prior and while notable players like Kaleb Geiger have done well earning spots on MLR rosters and even Eagles debuts, moving to SRA to compete closed the opportunity to really try the idea.
Final Thoughts
The dream of crossover success in rugby is enticing, but the reality is that it requires much more than just athletic ability. The unique demands of the sport, the steep learning curve for technical skills, the need for deep tactical awareness, and the distinct rugby culture all combine to make the transition extremely challenging. While some athletes have made the switch successfully, the majority struggle, highlighting that rugby is a sport that requires years of dedicated practice and experience to master. The idea of a smooth crossover into rugby is more of a myth than a reality.
Leave a Reply